Do you know about the Zone of Death loophole? This 50 square mile area in Yellowstone National Park allows for murder without consequence. The constitutional basis for this loophole is unclear, but its effects are significant.

Table of Contents

Yellowstone’s Zone of Death: 50 Square Mile Loophole for Murder?

The 2005 Georgetown Law Journal article “The Perfect Crime” described Yellowstone National Park’s “zone of death,” a 50 square-mile section tucked away in Idaho where a poorly worded law and a constitutional problem collide to create a place where one may commit felonies with impunity. After gaining attention in the 2021 disappearance of Gabby Petito, Idaho legislator Rep. Colin Nash is sponsoring House Joint Memorial 3 to call on Congress to close the zone of death loophole.

What is the Yellowstone Zone of Death?

The Zone of Death is an anomalous but legally significant area in the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park. It is a 50-square mile area where, because of a loophole in the Constitution of the United States, a person could theoretically commit any crime, up to and including murder, without consequence. This is because the U.S. District Court for the District of Wyoming currently has exclusive jurisdiction over the park, and thus any crime committed in the park cannot be prosecuted under any of the states’ laws.

The Zone of Death is important to visit for a number of reasons. First, it has captured the imaginations of true crime enthusiasts and presents a fascinating thought experiment. Second, it serves as a reminder that despite the advancements made in legal systems, there are still loopholes that can be exploited. Finally, it serves as a warning to remain vigilant and to constantly review and update legal systems to ensure that justice is served. Yellowstone is a unique and beautiful national park and the Zone of Death only serves to make it more interesting.

What Is the Loophole in The Zone of Death?

The Zone of Death is a 50-square-mile (129.50 km2) area in the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park in which, due to a legal loophole, a person could theoretically avoid conviction for any major crime, up to and including murder. This is because the area is not technically part of any state, and thus would have no jurisdiction over any crimes committed there. As a result, it would be impossible to form a jury, as the Sixth Amendment requires. This loophole was discovered by Michigan State University law professor, Brian Kalt, in 2005, and he has worked to have Congress close it. Despite this, Congress has failed to do so, leaving the Zone of Death as a legal anomaly.

What Caused the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park?

1. State Law

The loophole in the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park is a result of the Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution, which states that criminal defendants are entitled to a fair and quick trial by a jury of peers from both the state and district where the crime was committed. Due to the federal government’s exclusive jurisdiction over the park, the Idaho portion of the park is uninhabited, making it impossible to form a jury of residents from both the state and district. As a result, anyone charged with a crime in this area cannot be legally punished, regardless of guilt or innocence. This has been dubbed the “Zone of Death” as it creates a legal safe haven for criminals.

2. Twenty-fifth Amendment

The Twenty-fifth Amendment to the United States Constitution allows Congress to change the boundaries of a federal district and therefore affects the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park. This amendment, adopted in 1967, states that “Congress may by Law create additional Districts in any State, with the Consent of such State, for the purpose of providing for the Representation of such State in Congress.” This means that Congress can create a new district within a state or alter the boundaries of an existing district. In this case, Congress could create a new district encompassing the Idaho portion of Yellowstone National Park, or it could alter the existing boundaries of the District of Wyoming to include this area. This would effectively end the Zone of Death loophole, as it would provide for a jury composed of citizens living in the same district as the crime was committed.

3. Sixth Amendment

The Sixth Amendment to the United States Constitution, found in Article III, Section 2 and the 7th Amendment, guarantees the right to a fair and speedy trial by a jury of one’s peers. This is important in understanding the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park because it is an area with no permanent inhabitants, which means there are not enough eligible citizens to form a jury. This is the loophole that was discovered by Michigan State University law professor Brian C. Kalt, who realized that since there is no jury, there can be no trial and therefore no punishment for major crimes committed in the area.

This has led to the “Tabloid Constitutionalism” of the Zone of Death, where criminals could theoretically commit a crime in the park with impunity. This is why it is so important to understand and recognize the Sixth Amendment’s right to a jury trial in order to ensure justice is served in all areas of the United States, including the Zone of Death. While there are still other complications, such as only serious offenses being applicable to the right to trial, it is nonetheless essential to be aware of and uphold the Sixth Amendment to protect the rights of citizens.

4. National Park Service

The National Park Service has been aware of the so-called ‘Zone of Death’ in Yellowstone National Park for some time, and has been monitoring the situation closely. This area, which is located in the northeast corner of the park, is subject to a complex set of laws, including federal statutes, state laws, and local regulations. While the area is technically designated as a ‘no-man’s-land’, the National Park Service has taken steps to ensure the safety of visitors, including increased patrols and signage, and additional regulations to restrict access to the area when necessary. The National Park Service also works with local law enforcement to ensure that the area is not used for criminal activity of any kind.

5. Constitution

The Constitutional Lake Incident, also known as the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park, is an area where a person can commit a crime with relative impunity. This is due to a unique loophole in the U.S. Constitution discovered by Michigan State University law professor Brian C. Kalt in 2005. According to the Sixth Amendment, criminal defendants have the right to a fair and speedy trial. However, the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park has not enough eligible citizens to form a jury, which leads to the conclusion that there can be no trial and therefore no punishment for major crimes. This loophole gives criminals the opportunity to commit a crime without fear of punishment or legal repercussions. Kalt wrote an essay, called “The Perfect Crime”, in the Georgetown Law Journal in 2008 in an attempt to persuade the government to fix the loophole, but so far it has not been fixed. As a result, the Constitutional Lake Incident is notorious for being a place where people can commit crimes without risk of punishment.

6. States’ Rights

The cause of the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park is the “vicinage clause” of the Sixth Amendment of the United States Constitution. This clause states that members of a jury must be from both “the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed.” The federal government has exclusive jurisdiction in the park, and it put the entire park in the District of Wyoming, despite the fact that it spans three states. This means that the only place where one could live, both in Idaho and within the District of Wyoming, is in Yellowstone. Since no one lives there, it becomes impossible to select a jury, which violates criminal defendants’ right to a trial by jury, and thus, no trial can occur, and no conviction.

7. Lack of Jurisdiction

The lack of jurisdiction in Yellowstone National Park is caused by the fact that the federal government has exclusive jurisdiction over the park and put the entire park into the District of Wyoming, although the park spans three different states. This creates a problem due to the “vicinage clause” of the Sixth Amendment, which states that members of a jury must be from both “the State and district wherein the crime shall have been committed.” In order to satisfy this clause, jurors for a court case would have to be drawn from a small, 50-square-mile uninhabited region of the park, but no one lives in this area. As a result, no jury can be held, leading to a violation of criminal defendants’ right to a trial by jury, as enshrined in the Constitution.

8. Conspiracy Charges

Conspiracy charges in relation to the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park refer to the fact that a person could commit a major crime in the area and not be subject to prosecution due to a loophole in the United States Constitution. The Sixth Amendment states that juries in federal criminal cases must be made up of citizens who are from both the district and state where the crime was committed. As the Zone of Death extends slightly beyond Wyoming’s boundaries into Idaho and Montana, and since the federal government has exclusive jurisdiction over the park, the area is unable to form a jury from two different states and thus the accused is not subject to prosecution. This loophole was discovered by Michigan State University law professor Brian C. Kalt, and he published an essay entitled “The Perfect Crime” in The Georgetown Law Journal in 2005 in an attempt to persuade the government to fix the loophole.

9. Yellowstone’s Tourism Economy

The effect of the tourism economy on the Zone of Death in Yellowstone National Park is that it has become a hotspot for travelers looking to experience something unique. Tourists to the area are drawn to the mystery and intrigue of the Zone of Death, and this heightened interest has resulted in an influx of visitors looking to experience the area. This increased tourism has resulted in increased economic activity, with hotels, restaurants, and tour companies all benefiting from the influx of visitors. Additionally, with more people visiting the area, local governments have had to increase their enforcement of existing laws to ensure the safety of visitors.

Why Is the Zone of Death a Loophole for Murder?

The Zone of Death is a loophole for murder due to the discrepancy between the US Constitution and the jurisdiction of Yellowstone National Park. According to the Sixth Amendment, federal crimes must be prosecuted in the state and district where the crime is committed. However, in the Zone of Death, the federal district of Wyoming has full jurisdiction over the entire park, meaning that if a crime was committed in the Zone of Death, it could only be prosecuted using the population of people who live in that 50-mile area. Since no one lives in the Zone of Death, it would be impossible to prosecute someone for a crime committed there. This means that if someone were to commit a murder in the Zone of Death, they would not be able to be prosecuted and could potentially get away with their crime. This loophole has been acknowledged by Congress but is not considered a priority for them to fix. While no one has been arrested for crimes committed in the Zone of Death, if someone were to take advantage of this loophole, they could get away with murder.

How Many Murders Have Been Committed in The Zone of Death?

To date, there have been no known felonies committed in the Zone of Death since the discovery of the loophole in 2005. However, a poacher named Michael Belderrain illegally shot an elk in the Montana section of Yellowstone, which is located in the Zone of Death. Belderrain took a plea deal, so the issue was not further challenged in court. Thus, there have been no murders committed in the Zone of Death since its discovery.

Courtroom Gavel Judge Court Hearing by weiss paarz photos is licensed under CC BY SA 2.0.

FAQs

What is the Yellowstone’s Zone of Death?

The Yellowstone’s Zone of Death is a 50 square mile area in the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park in which, due to a legal loophole, a person could theoretically avoid conviction for any major crime, up to and including murder. This is because the United States District Court for the District of Wyoming is the only court with jurisdiction over the park, and it has exclusive jurisdiction over the park, so state laws do not apply. This anomaly is caused by the fact that Yellowstone National Park extends slightly beyond Wyoming’s boundaries into Idaho and Montana.

What is the significance of the 50 square mile area in the Zone of Death?

The Zone of Death is a 50 square mile area in the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park where, due to a legal loophole in the United States Constitution, a person could theoretically get away with any major crime, up to and including murder. This loophole occurs due to the fact that the United States District Court for the District of Wyoming has jurisdiction over the entire park, which extends slightly beyond Wyoming’s boundaries into Idaho. This means that crimes committed in the park are not under the jurisdiction of any state laws, making it difficult for a criminal to be prosecuted for a crime within the Zone of Death.

This situation presents a unique and troubling problem for the justice system, as potentially dangerous criminals could use this loophole to their advantage. It is a great example of how legal loopholes can be exploited to avoid prosecution, and serves as a reminder of how important it is to ensure that the laws are up to date and accurately reflect the current state of affairs.

What is the constitutional basis for the Zone of Death loophole?

The Zone of Death loophole is based on a constitutional conflict between the 6th Amendment, which guarantees the right to a trial in the state and district where a crime has allegedly been committed, and Article III of the US Constitution, which states that federal courts can only hear cases in their jurisdiction. The conflict arises when a crime is committed in a location that is covered by more than one state or district, such as Yellowstone National Park, which is part of Wyoming, Montana, and Idaho. In such a case, the criminal could be tried by any of the three states, but the 6th Amendment guarantees that the criminal must be tried in the state and district where the crime was committed. This means that if the criminal is tried in a state or district other than the one in which the crime was committed, the 6th Amendment has been violated, and the criminal could potentially be acquitted. This is the loophole Kalt identified in his 2008 article and is the basis for the Zone of Death loophole.

How did the Zone of Death become the subject of an email?

The email about the “Zone of Death” became a popular meme after internet sleuths began speculating on the possibility of the area playing a role in the disappearance of YouTuber Gabby Petito. After reading a 2005 essay by Michigan State University law professor, Brian Kalt, which explained the legal loophole that made the Zone of Death virtually prosecution-proof, the morbid fascination of the area grew. This increased attention on the Zone of Death prompted C.J. Box to write a novel about the area, called Free Fire. In turn, this novel alerted Wyoming Senator Mike Enzi to the issue, but he was unable to convince Congress to address it. Word of the Zone of Death spread, and soon enough it had become a popular meme.

What is the Idaho State Law regarding the Zone of Death?

The Idaho State Law regarding the Zone of Death is a legal loophole that has been identified in the Constitution of the United States. The 50-square-mile area in the Idaho section of Yellowstone National Park, where this loophole exists, is referred to as the Zone of Death. This loophole states that due to the Sixth Amendment, a person charged with a federal crime in this area could theoretically avoid conviction, as no jury of peers could be selected from the Idaho portion of the park. The only beings living in this area are wildlife, which are ineligible for jury duty. To address this issue, Representative Colin Nash of Boise has sponsored a joint memorial to Congress, asking them to close this loophole. If passed, this would ensure that anyone accused of a federal crime in this area could be properly prosecuted.

What are the implications of the Zone of Death loophole?

The Zone of Death loophole has the potential to allow criminals to evade justice if they commit a crime in the Zone of Death. Craig Kalt, a legal expert, worked to have Congress close this loophole, but Congress ignored his suggestion. This has led to an unresolved legal issue. Michael Belderrain, a poacher, illegally shot an elk in the Montana section of Yellowstone and was indicted in the US District Court for the District of Wyoming. He objected that he had a right to be tried by jurors from the Montana portion of the park. The court dismissed this argument and Belderrain took a plea deal which included a provision barring him from appealing this precise issue to the Tenth Circuit Court of Appeals. Consequently, the Zone of Death loophole remains unresolved, leaving it open for potential criminals to exploit.

What is the Idaho State Legislature doing to address the Zone of Death loophole?

Step-by-step instructions include reaching out to the current Congressional delegation to see their feelings on the issue and to request advice on legislative language. Currently, Senator Michael Crapo’s (R-Idaho) communications director has stated that Congressionals have asked for advice but have not received any from the relevant executive branch agencies. Professor Kalt of Stanford University has drafted language to potentially fix the loophole, which includes striking out certain sections of the US Code and amending them. Senator Jim Risch (R-Idaho) believes the issue is not a major concern, as the area affected is small and the crime rate is low, though Professor Kalt disputes this point. Neither Rep. Simpson nor Rep. Ral Labrador (R-Idaho) have commented on the issue.

How has the Zone of Death loophole been featured in the media?

The Zone of Death loophole, which was discovered by legal expert CJ Kalt in 2008, has been featured numerous times in the media. It began with Kalt’s article in the Montana Law Review, which sparked a press blitz and attracted the attention of then-Senator Larry Craig (R-Idaho), who promised to look into the issue. Later, author CJ Box released a novel, Free Fire, which was inspired by Kalt’s article. Senator Mike Enzi (R-Wyoming) then asked the Department of Justice to look into the loophole, which led to a determination that no fix was needed. However, Kalt and Enzi argued that this was wrong, as the loophole violated one’s Sixth Amendment right to a trial in the state and district where the crime allegedly occurred.

When Senator Mike Lee (R-Utah) was elected, Kalt was hopeful that the loophole would be fixed. However, Lee has been “otherwise occupied” and the loophole remains. Kalt has continued to work to have Congress close the loophole, but officials have been too busy dealing with more pressing matters to address it. As a result, the Zone of Death loophole remains in place, a reminder of the need for greater attention and reform of the justice system.

What are the potential solutions to the Zone of Death loophole?

The potential solutions to the Zone of Death loophole include changing the legal argument that trying someone in the wrong state or district is a “harmless error”; amending the Wyoming district court to include the Zone of Death; splitting Yellowstone into the district courts for Wyoming, Idaho, and Montana, thus creating a new and unwelcome burden for environmentalist to challenge the Park Service’s management decisions in the liberal and quirky Ninth Circuit; and for Congress to take up the issue and discuss it. Another potential solution suggested by C.J. Box’s novel Free Fire is to increase governmental awareness of the loophole, which did lead to Senator Mike Enzi (R-Wyoming) asking the Department of Justice to look into the issue. Ultimately, the Department concluded that a fix was needed, but the issue remains unresolved to this day.

Final Thoughts

Rep. Colin Nash’s House Joint Memorial 3 is a call to action for Congress to close the legal loophole that exists in Yellowstone National Park’s “zone of death,” a 50 square-mile section of Idaho where felonies may be committed with impunity. This memorial seeks to guarantee that any criminal defendants tried for a crime committed in this specific area may still be able to invoke their Sixth Amendment right to be tried in front of a jury from the state and district where the crime occurred.

Happy Trails,